Overhead and Profit on Insurance Estimates: the Three-Trade Rule
Overhead and profit is the general contractor's share of a repair estimate. Here is what 10 and 10 means, the three-trade convention and its limits, what counts as a trade, and how to calculate and document it.
vPlan AR Team
vPlan AR
Overhead and profit (O&P) is the line on a repair estimate that pays the general contractor for running the job: scheduling the trades, ordering materials, supervising, carrying insurance, and making a margin. On property claims it is one of the most argued-over lines, because whether it applies at all often comes down to one question: does this repair need a general contractor?
This guide explains what O&P covers, the "10 and 10" convention, the three-trade rule and where it falls short, what counts as a trade, how to calculate it, and how to show it so an adjuster, a contractor and a homeowner read the same number.
What Overhead and Profit Is
Overhead is what it costs to run the business rather than any one line of work: office and estimating time, vehicles, insurance, licences, project management. Profit is what the company earns for taking on the job and its risk. Line items for drywall or paint are priced as the trade's cost to do that work; O&P is the general contractor's cost and margin on top, for organising all of it.
That is why O&P belongs to jobs a general contractor runs. A homeowner hiring one painter directly pays the painter's price, which already carries the painter's own overhead and profit.
"10 and 10"
On insurance repair estimates the usual figures are 10% overhead and 10% profit, written "10 and 10". They are a convention of the claims industry, not a rule: contractors in some markets, and on some kinds of work, use other figures, and carriers' guidelines vary. Whatever the percentages, they are shown as two separate lines so anyone reading the estimate can see them.
The Three-Trade Rule and Its Limits
The three-trade rule says O&P applies when a repair needs three or more trades, the point at which coordinating them is a job in itself. It is a rule of thumb used in many carrier guidelines and estimating habits; it isn't a law, and insurance policies don't usually mention it.
It is also only a proxy for the real question, whether a general contractor is reasonably needed. A two-trade job can still need one (a kitchen ceiling that has to be opened, dried out, rebuilt and inspected in the right order, with a permit), and a four-trade job on a single wall may not. In some states, regulators and courts have looked at whether a general contractor was reasonably needed rather than counting trades. When O&P is disputed, the job's complexity and sequencing make the case, not the count alone.
What Counts as a Trade
A trade is a distinct kind of skilled work, usually done by a different crew or subcontractor: drywall, painting, flooring, tile, finish carpentry (trim, baseboard, doors), insulation, framing, cabinetry, countertops, plumbing, electrical, roofing, HVAC, cleaning.
Some lines don't count, because they are part of running the job rather than a trade of their own: general conditions such as the permit, the dumpster and floor protection; demolition and debris removal; contents handling. Emergency mitigation (extraction, drying, tear-out) is usually its own estimate, below. Count the trades from the work lines, not from materials: a flooring job doesn't become three trades because the rooms also have paint and baseboard listed as finishes.
How to Calculate It
Add the line items to a subtotal, add any contingency or waste allowance, then apply overhead and profit to that figure. Take a rebuild after a water loss in a kitchen and hallway: drywall, insulation, painting, flooring and baseboard, five trades. The lines come to $9,000 and contingency adds $500, so O&P is worked on $9,500: 10% overhead is $950, 10% profit another $950, and the estimate totals $11,400.
Replace only the carpet in one bedroom and it is a single trade: by the three-trade convention there is no O&P, and the carpet installer's price stands on its own.
Mitigation and Overhead and Profit
Water and mold mitigation is emergency work done by the mitigation company itself: extraction, flood cuts, tear-out, drying equipment by the day, monitoring. Its rates are usually all-inclusive, and it is written as its own estimate, apart from the rebuild. Keeping the two apart stops O&P being argued over emergency services and keeps the rebuild estimate to the work a general contractor coordinates.
Showing It on the Estimate
Show overhead and profit as two separate lines with their percentages, below the subtotal and contingency, and list the trades the job takes. If the job needs a general contractor for reasons beyond the count (sequencing, a permit and inspections, work in occupied rooms), say so in the summary. A measured floor plan and room-by-room quantities help too: a reviewer who can see each room's scope can see why the work needs coordinating. Our guide to estimating abbreviations covers the room measurements those quantities come from.
How vPlan AR Handles It
In vPlan AR's web editor, the Scope tab writes mitigation, reconstruction and remodel as three separate estimates. A Reconstruction or Remodel estimate adds 10% overhead and 10% profit by default, on the subtotal plus contingency, when its work lines take three or more trades, and the exported estimate lists the trades it counted. Mitigation never adds O&P. A line's trade comes from its item's category; permits, dumpsters, protection, demolition, contents and mitigation work count as none, and finishes listed for the rooms don't add trades.
Change the percentages in Settings → Estimate Rate Card, and for any export choose Automatic (3 or more trades), Include or Leave out, for a job that needs a general contractor with fewer trades, or one that doesn't with more. Estimates are on Pro and Business. Watch a reconstruction estimate with overhead and profit, or see the pages for restoration contractors, insurance adjusters and contractors.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the three-trade rule for overhead and profit?
A rule of thumb used on property claims: overhead and profit apply when a repair needs three or more trades, because coordinating them is a general contractor's job. It isn't a law or a policy term, and the deciding question is whether a general contractor is reasonably needed.
Is 10 and 10 overhead and profit standard?
10% overhead and 10% profit is the usual figure on insurance repair estimates, but it is a convention: some contractors and markets use other percentages. Show each as its own line so the figures are clear.
Can you get overhead and profit with fewer than three trades?
Sometimes. If the job genuinely needs a general contractor, for example because of sequencing, permits and inspections, or work that must be opened, dried and rebuilt in order, explain that in the estimate. Carriers' guidelines and state rules differ.
Does mitigation get overhead and profit?
Mitigation is usually written as its own estimate with all-inclusive rates, apart from the rebuild, and without overhead and profit. The rebuild estimate is where overhead and profit is applied when a general contractor runs the repair.
Is overhead and profit calculated before or after contingency?
It is usually applied to the subtotal including contingency or waste: line items, plus contingency, then overhead and profit on that figure. In vPlan AR, $9,500 of work and contingency at 10 and 10 adds $950 and $950.